Top Oyster Bars 2025 in
New York, New York
The Ultimate Oyster Bar Guide: Where to Find the Best Shucks in Town
There’s nothing quite like the briny freshness of a perfectly shucked oyster, whether you love them raw, grilled, or dressed up with flavorful toppings. From cozy hidden gems to upscale seafood havens, we’ve scoured the scene to bring you the top oyster bars that every seafood lover should try.
At Nearest Oyster, we know that a great oyster bar is about more than just fresh shellfish—it’s about the experience. Whether you’re looking for a lively spot to enjoy happy hour, a romantic seafood dinner, or a casual place to indulge in some of the best oysters around, we’ve got you covered.
Check out our top picks and get ready to discover your next favorite oyster bar!
At Nearest Oyster, we know that a great oyster bar is about more than just fresh shellfish—it’s about the experience. Whether you’re looking for a lively spot to enjoy happy hour, a romantic seafood dinner, or a casual place to indulge in some of the best oysters around, we’ve got you covered.
Check out our top picks and get ready to discover your next favorite oyster bar!
1.
Ama Raw Bar East Village
190 Avenue B, New York, NY 10009
Welcome to Ama Raw Bar East Village, where the charm of the East Village meets a cozy nautical vibe! This trendy seafood spot has been serving up delicious, no-frills oysters since 1917. With its simple yet stylish decor, you're in for an inviting experience that feels both upscale and laid-back. Whether you're grabbing a quick takeout or enjoying a cozy meal, Ama is here to make your oyster dreams come true. The menu? Straightforward seafood goodness that highlights the star of the show: the oysters!
Why we love it
We love Ama Raw Bar for its consistently fresh oysters and a happy hour that’s perfect for unwinding after a long day! With a stellar 4.7 Google review score, it's clear that this place knows how to please oyster lovers. Plus, the warmth of the staff makes you feel right at home. Whether you’re a raw oyster newcomer or a seasoned shucker, the friendly vibe and top-notch seafood at Ama make it a must-visit in New York City. So, why wait? Treat yourself to the oyster party you've been craving!
2.
upstate craft beer & oyster bar
95 1st Ave., New York, NY 10003
Welcome to Upstate Craft Beer & Oyster Bar, a trendy spot where the freshness of the sea meets the best of local brews! Nestled on 1st Avenue, this upscale eatery is not just about shucking oysters; it’s a celebration of all things seafood. With a menu featuring chowders, fried fish, and delectable sandwiches, Upstate is the perfect pitstop for anyone looking to indulge their taste buds. Plus, the outdoor seating offers lovely bay views that make every bite even more enjoyable!
Why we love it
We love Upstate because it’s where seafood lovers can truly rejoice! The quality of their oysters is top-notch, and their happy hour makes it an even better excuse to gather your friends for a delightful evening. The vibe is fun and trendy, perfect for unwinding after a busy day or enjoying a casual meetup. It’s clear why this place has a glowing 4.6-star rating—it’s cozy, fresh, and has a menu that keeps you coming back for more. Don’t forget to take advantage of their takeout if you want to enjoy these ocean treasures at home!
3.
Mermaid Oyster Bar
89 MacDougal St, New York, NY 10012
Nestled in the heart of Greenwich Village, Mermaid Oyster Bar is a charming seafood haven that brings a touch of the beach to New York City. With its cozy and romantic ambiance, this upscale eatery serves up a delightful selection of fresh oysters alongside a tantalizing lobster and raw bar. Whether you’re in the mood for a quiet dinner or a trendy night out, the warm vibes and inviting decor make it the perfect spot to unwind and indulge.
Why we love it
We love Mermaid Oyster Bar because it’s not just about the oysters—it's an experience! With a happy hour that promises great deals and a welcoming atmosphere, it’s ideal for gathering with friends or impressing a date. Plus, who can resist the allure of slurping down some of the freshest shellfish while feeling like you’ve escaped to a seaside getaway? This bar truly captures the essence of coastal dining, right in the heart of NYC!
4.
Sagaponack
4 W 22nd St, New York, NY 10010
Nestled in the heart of New York at 4 W 22nd St, Sagaponack is your go-to cozy spot for an upscale seafood feast! With a warm and inviting vibe, this oyster bar serves up not only fresh oysters but also a delightful selection of seafood and indulgent desserts. The star of the show? Their Prince Edward Island mussels, prepared in a variety of delicious ways that keep you coming back for more. With a solid Google review score of 4.6, you know you're in for a treat!
Why we love it
Sagaponack isn't just an oyster bar; it's a culinary experience that feels both trendy and comforting. Whether you're stopping by for a happy hour with friends or a special date night, the intimate atmosphere makes every moment memorable. Plus, who can resist that combination of fresh shellfish and delectable mussels? It's the perfect spot to take a break from the hustle and bustle of the city while still enjoying the best of what New York's seafood scene has to offer. Grab a seat, order a dozen, and enjoy the fresh flavors right at your fingertips!
5.
Crave Fishbar
945 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022
Tucked away on 2nd Avenue, Crave Fishbar is a stylish seafood haven that has been serving up East Coast delights since 1976. With its cozy and trendy vibe, it's the perfect spot to indulge in a variety of mouthwatering oysters, fresh lobster, and other seafood classics. Though you can't dine in, their takeout service allows you to enjoy a seafood feast wherever you choose!
Why we love it
We love Crave Fishbar for its unmatched quality and flavorful dishes that keep us coming back for more. With a stellar Google review score of 4.5 from over 1,100 happy diners, it’s clear that this spot knows how to please! Plus, who can resist a fantastic happy hour? Whether you’re treating yourself or sharing with friends, Crave Fishbar makes seafood dining fun and easy!
