Top Oyster Bars 2025 in
Portland, Maine
The Ultimate Oyster Bar Guide: Where to Find the Best Shucks in Town
There’s nothing quite like the briny freshness of a perfectly shucked oyster, whether you love them raw, grilled, or dressed up with flavorful toppings. From cozy hidden gems to upscale seafood havens, we’ve scoured the scene to bring you the top oyster bars that every seafood lover should try.
At Nearest Oyster, we know that a great oyster bar is about more than just fresh shellfish—it’s about the experience. Whether you’re looking for a lively spot to enjoy happy hour, a romantic seafood dinner, or a casual place to indulge in some of the best oysters around, we’ve got you covered.
Check out our top picks and get ready to discover your next favorite oyster bar!
At Nearest Oyster, we know that a great oyster bar is about more than just fresh shellfish—it’s about the experience. Whether you’re looking for a lively spot to enjoy happy hour, a romantic seafood dinner, or a casual place to indulge in some of the best oysters around, we’ve got you covered.
Check out our top picks and get ready to discover your next favorite oyster bar!
1.
The Shop by Island Creek Oysters
123 Washington Ave, Portland, ME 04101
Welcome to The Shop by Island Creek Oysters, the crown jewel of oyster bars in Portland! Nestled on Washington Ave, this cozy and charming spot combines historic vibe with modern flair, making it a go-to destination for oyster lovers. With a bustling raw bar where you can watch fresh shellfish being shucked right before your eyes, each visit feels like a delightful culinary adventure. And let’s not forget the seasonal patio—perfect for enjoying your oysters al fresco when the weather allows!
Why we love it
We love The Shop because it’s not just about the oysters (though they are absolutely fantastic!); it’s the whole experience. Whether you're looking for a romantic date night or a fun happy hour with friends, this trendy spot has got you covered. With a stellar Google review score of 9.6, it’s clear that everyone else loves it too! The warm atmosphere, exceptional service, and mouthwatering oysters make it a must-visit for seafood lovers. Treat yourself to a plate, grab a glass of wine, and enjoy the good life at The Shop!
2.
Maine Oyster Company
38 Portland St, Portland, ME 04101
Nestled in the heart of Portland, Maine Oyster Company is a cozy and historic seafood haven that transports you straight to the ocean with every bite. This trendy spot isn't just about delicious oysters; they also serve up mouth-watering lobster rolls and a selection of craft beers that perfectly complement your meal. With a warm and inviting vibe, it's a romantic choice for couples looking to share fresh seafood in a chic atmosphere. Plus, their oyster tasting and shucking classes mean you can learn a thing or two about these tasty treats while you indulge!
Why we love it
We love Maine Oyster Company for its unbeatable combination of fresh seafood and a delightful atmosphere. With a Google review score of 4.9 from 170 happy customers, it's clear that they deliver a top-notch experience every time. Happy hour lovers rejoice, because this place has you covered! And if you're in a hurry, their takeout service ensures you can enjoy your favorite oysters wherever you are. Whether you're a seasoned oyster aficionado or just looking to try something new, Maine Oyster Company is a fantastic spot to dive into the briny goodness.
3.
Blyth & Burrows
26 Exchange St, Portland, ME 04101
Nestled in the heart of downtown Portland, Blyth & Burrows is a vintage-inspired cocktail bar that exudes maritime charm. With its upscale small plates and expertly crafted house cocktails, this bar strikes the perfect balance between cozy and trendy. The historic decor transports you to a bygone era, making it an ideal spot for those looking to enjoy oysters in a romantic ambiance. While it’s a great place to sit back and relax, you can also take your favorite dishes to-go, making it a flexible option for any occasion.
Why we love it
We love Blyth & Burrows because it’s more than just an oyster bar—it’s a whole experience! Whether you’re sipping on a perfectly crafted cocktail or indulging in fresh oysters, the vibe here is simply unbeatable. With a stellar Google review score of 4.8 from over 1400 satisfied customers, this bar has become a trending favorite. Plus, their happy hour offers a fantastic opportunity to enjoy upscale bites without breaking the bank. Whether you're planning a romantic date night or a fun outing with friends, you’ll leave feeling delighted and eager to return!
4.
Eventide Oyster Co.
86 Middle St, Portland, ME 04101
Nestled in the heart of Portland, Eventide Oyster Co. is a cozy, historic gem that beckons seafood lovers from near and far. With its bustling raw bar and a menu that expertly fuses traditional New England fare with creative twists, this tiny seafood joint has become a must-visit destination. Whether you're craving a classic lobster roll or their famed oysters, you'll find the perfect bite here. The inviting ambiance, complete with a romantic touch and a dash of trendiness, makes it an ideal spot for a special night out or a casual indulgence.
Why we love it
We love Eventide Oyster Co. for its unforgettable experience and commitment to quality. With a fantastic Google review score of 4.5 from over 4,000 happy customers, you can trust that this place knows how to serve up oysters with flair. Plus, their happy hour offers a great way to savor these delicacies without breaking the bank! While dine-in may not be an option, their convenient take-out service means you can enjoy a delicious seafood feast anywhere you like. If you want a cozy, upscale spot to treat your taste buds, Eventide is the place to be!
5.
J’s Oyster
5 Portland Pier, Portland, ME 04101
Tucked away on Portland Pier, J's Oyster is a cozy yet upscale eatery that feels like a hidden gem. This charming spot is famous for its scrumptious oysters, steamed clams, and other coastal classics that will transport your taste buds straight to the sea.
Why we love it
We love J's Oyster for its perfect blend of a relaxing atmosphere and delicious food! With a great happy hour, it's the ideal place to unwind with friends or enjoy a romantic evening. Plus, their commitment to quality and freshness shines through every bite. Whether you're stopping by for a quick pick-up or simply want some delicious shellfish to enjoy at home, J's Oyster won't let you down. Dive into the flavors of Maine right at this delightful spot!
